Morphological pathogenesis: how the joint changes
Disease progression is accompanied by a predictable sequence of structural changes that can be clearly visualized using instrumental diagnostics:
- Cartilage damage: First, the turgor of the cartilage tissue decreases, and fissures appear. Gradually, the destruction deepens down to the subchondral bone. As a result, the joint space steadily narrows, and in end-stage disease, it is barely traceable.
- Subchondral sclerosis: Due to the loss of cartilaginous shock absorption, the bone undergoes compensatory densification in the most heavily loaded areas. This osteosclerosis progresses even in late stages, despite concurrent disuse osteoporosis.
- Bone cysts: Microfractures occur in the epiphyseal zone of the subchondral bone. Cysts form in their place (seen on radiographs as oval radiolucencies with clear margins), and some of them may rupture into the joint cavity.
- Osteophytes: Bone spurs appear at the boundary with the hyaline cartilage, at the attachment sites of ligaments and the capsule. Gradually, they increase in size and dramatically alter the configuration of the joint.
- Bone impression: In areas of maximum load, the articular surface "collapses." This leads to dyscongruence (mismatch of the shapes of articular surfaces) and the formation of subluxations.
- Soft tissue changes: Portions of the capsule may ossify. When detached fragments undergo sclerosis within the cavity, so-called "joint mice" (loose bodies) are formed.
Stages of cartilage destruction (ICRS classification)
The International Cartilage Repair Society (ICRS) identifies 4 stages of damage. This classification is critically important because the state of the cartilage determines the treatment strategy and prognosis:
- Stage I: Softening and decreased turgor (determined by palpation with an arthroscopic hook), shallow superficial fissures.
- Stage II: Cartilage destruction and delamination of superficial fragments not reaching the subchondral bone.
- Stage III: Damage to a significant depth, up to a linear transchondral fracture (destruction reaches the bone).
- Stage IV: Total destruction of both the articular cartilage and the underlying subchondral bone.
Clinical and radiological presentation (N.S. Kosinskaya stages)
N.S. Kosinskaya's classification takes into account both radiological changes and clinical symptoms (pain, contractures, crepitus).
- Stage I: Minor joint space narrowing, small osteophytes, local ossification of the cartilage. Clinically: Moderate limitation of movement. There is no pain at rest; it appears only after prolonged exertion or as "start-up pain" at the beginning of movement.
- Stage II: Joint space narrowing by 2–3 times, subchondral sclerosis, appearance of bone cysts and gross osteophytes. Clinically: Severe pain syndrome (subsides only after prolonged unloading), coarse crepitus. Contractures develop, leading to functional limb shortening, limp, pelvic tilt, and secondary scoliosis (due to altered statics and excessive load on the intervertebral discs).
- Stage III: Joint space is almost absent, pronounced bone impression and surface deformation, severe sclerosis, possible presence of "joint mice". Clinically: Almost complete loss of mobility, with only rocking movements remaining.
- In coxarthrosis (damage to the hip joint), "stiff leg" syndrome develops: the femur moves only together with the pelvis, and the patient walks with crutches.
- In gonarthrosis (damage to the knee joint), a flexion contracture occurs with marked lateral deformity of the axis (most commonly varus).
Kellgren–Lawrence radiological grades
This grading system is based exclusively on radiography data:
| Grade | Characteristic | Radiological signs |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | None | Normal |
| I | Doubtful | Minute osteophytes of doubtful significance. Joint space narrowing not clearly apparent |
| II | Minimal | Definite osteophytes and possible joint space narrowing |
| III | Moderate | Multiple osteophytes, definite joint space narrowing, sclerosis |
| IV | Severe | Marked joint space narrowing with sclerosis and definite deformity of bone ends |
Laboratory and instrumental diagnostics
Osteoarthritis is characterized by the absence of systemic inflammation. Complete blood counts and urinalyses show no abnormalities. The ESR remains within 20–25 mm/h, even if secondary synovitis develops. The synovial fluid retains normal viscosity, the cell count does not exceed $5 \cdot 10^3$ per 1 mm³, and the proportion of neutrophils is less than 50%.
Instrumental methods:
- Ultrasound and MRI: Allow visualization of the capsule, ligaments, menisci, precise sizing of cysts, and detection of non-radiopaque cartilage inclusions.
- Radiography: The baseline method for detecting osteophytes, space narrowing, and sclerosis.
- CT: Considered uninformative for diagnosing osteoarthritis.
- Arthroscopy: An endoscopic method for direct visual assessment of cartilage.
For a comprehensive assessment of the severity of large joint damage, the Lequesne Index (Lequesne Index) is used, which sums up points for morning stiffness, pain, pain-free walking distance, and activities of daily living.
Briefly: answers to topical questions
What is the complete pathogenesis of subchondral bone cyst formation in osteoarthritis?
The pathogenesis of subchondral bone cyst formation is due to the loss of the cartilage's shock-absorbing function and subsequent ischemia. Increased loading on the bone causes subchondral osteosclerosis. Bone tissue degeneration leads to venous stasis and increased intraosseous pressure, which disrupts cartilage nutrition and causes local ischemia. As a result of ischemia, oval defects (cysts) filled with loose granulation tissue form in the cancellous bone. Due to microfractures of the subchondral bone, some superficial cysts may rupture into the joint cavity, leading to the development of erosive osteoarthritis.
What types of osteophytes are distinguished based on their location in the joint?
Depending on their location in the joint, the following types of osteophytes are distinguished:
- Marginal osteophytes — form along the edges of the acetabulum, articular surfaces, or vertebral bodies, increasing the depth of the socket and deforming the joint.
- Central osteophytes — form in the central zone (e.g., of the acetabulum), causing its lateralization.
- Attachment site osteophytes — mild bone spurs and osteocartilaginous overgrowths in areas of cartilage-soft tissue contact (at the attachment sites of ligaments, capsule, and synovial membrane at the border with hyaline cartilage).
To remember the progression of radiological signs according to Kosinskaya: Stage I — Space + Osteophytes; Stage II — Sclerosis + Cysts are added; Stage III — Bone impression (destruction) is added.
Class and exam questions
Why aren't «joint mice» always visible on standard radiographs?
Loose intra-articular bodies often consist of pure hyaline cartilage, which is radiolucent. They are visualized on radiographs only if the fragments have an osteocartilaginous structure, undergo sclerosis, or ossify.
What conditions must osteoarthritis be differentiated from?
Primarily with rheumatoid arthritis, psoriatic arthritis, ankylosing spondylitis, gout, avascular bone necrosis, Paget's disease, and metastases. It is important to remember that secondary osteoarthritis can develop against the background of these pathologies.
Which clinical syndromes are characteristic of stage III coxarthrosis?
The main sign is the "stiff leg" syndrome. Due to the formation of severe contracture, movements in the hip joint become impossible, and during walking, the femur is forced to move only together with the pelvis.
What else to study on this topic
- Criteria for secondary osteoarthritis against the background of autoimmune pathologies.
- Principles of calculating the Lequesne index in clinical practice.
- Differential diagnosis with gout and Bechterew's disease.
- Conservative treatment: approaches to managing reactive synovitis.
- Mechanism of formation of arthrogenic and myogenic contractures.
Master the entire topic in the "Traumatology" course
This is a summary. The course covers everything tested in classes and exams.
- Complete study guide on «Pathogenesis of Osteoarthritis» and 812 more pages on the subject
- Assignments and quizzes after every topic — just like in a colloquium
- AI tutor answers questions on the topic anytime
- 35 video lessons on the subject
Other Topics in "Orthopedics"
Prepared by WhiteCoat Pro faculty in accordance with the medical school curriculum. For educational purposes only.